Experienced Financial Controller Needed for Religious & Educational Nonprofit

Location: New York City, NY 10065

Financial Controller – Lead Nonprofit Finance & Operations

Job Type: Full-Time, In-Person

A nonprofit religious and educational organization is seeking a Financial Controller to oversee financial operations, ensuring compliance, efficiency, and accuracy. This role requires close collaboration with leadership, clergy, and administrative staff to maintain financial stability and sustainability.

Key Responsibilities:

Financial Management & Reporting:

  • Oversee all financial records, ensuring accuracy and compliance with nonprofit accounting principles.
  • Manage accounts payable and receivable, including processing monthly organization statements and preparing interim financials as needed.
  • Handle online banking, prepare cash reports, conduct bank reconciliations, and oversee monthly credit card bill allocations.
  • Generate financial reports such as outstanding balances and prior donation reports for solicitations.
  • Lead the year-end audit process, including audited financial statements and IRS Form 990.

Payroll & Employee Administration:

  • Process payroll for both religious and educational divisions, including journal entries in QuickBooks.
  • Oversee employee benefits administration and serve as the liaison with insurance providers.
  • Manage the UKG scanning system for payroll and HR documentation.
  • Conduct background checks for new employees and oversee employment documentation.

Board & Leadership Support:

  • Present financial reports and key insights to leadership.
  • Assist in financial planning, budgeting, and cost-saving strategies.
  • Provide financial consultation to key staff and administrators.

Qualifications & Experience:

  • Bachelor’s degree in Accounting, Finance, or related field (CPA or Master’s degree preferred).
  • 3-5 years of financial management experience, ideally in a nonprofit or educational setting.
  • Proficiency in QuickBooks, Excel, and other accounting software.
  • Strong organizational, analytical, and communication skills.

Compensation & Benefits:

  • Competitive salary based on experience.
  • Health insurance and other benefits.
  • Paid time off and holidays in accordance with organizational policies.

This is an excellent opportunity to contribute to a meaningful mission within a dynamic community-focused organization.